• Main News
  • About Us
  • Contact
Premium Times Opinion
Sunday, January 29, 2023
  • Home
  • Democracy and Governance
    • Bámidélé Upfront
    • Jibrin Ibrahim
    • Okey Ndibe
  • Economy
    • Ifeanyi Uddin
  • Issues of the Day
    • Adeolu Ademoyo
    • Aribisala on Tuesday
    • Dele Agekameh
    • Pius Adesanmi
  • Politics
    • Ebeneezer Obadare
    • Femi Fani-Kayode
    • Garba Shehu
    • Hannatu Musawa
    • Zainab Suleiman Okino
  • Guest Columns
  • Faith
    • Article of Faith
    • Sunday Ogidigbo
    • Friday Sermon
    • Elevated Sight
  • Home
  • Democracy and Governance
    • Bámidélé Upfront
    • Jibrin Ibrahim
    • Okey Ndibe
  • Economy
    • Ifeanyi Uddin
  • Issues of the Day
    • Adeolu Ademoyo
    • Aribisala on Tuesday
    • Dele Agekameh
    • Pius Adesanmi
  • Politics
    • Ebeneezer Obadare
    • Femi Fani-Kayode
    • Garba Shehu
    • Hannatu Musawa
    • Zainab Suleiman Okino
  • Guest Columns
  • Faith
    • Article of Faith
    • Sunday Ogidigbo
    • Friday Sermon
    • Elevated Sight
No Result
View All Result
Premium Times Opinion

Questioning the Legitimacy of Nigeria as a Federal Republic, By Tony Osborg

by Premium Times
November 19, 2016
Reading Time: 4 mins read
0

Nigeria

Technically, Nigeria is not a legitimate country because more than half of the people and states that make it did not give consent to its creation. A country has legitimacy when ALL of its people give it authority to act on their behalf.


There is a standard procedure for establishing a country on the basis of the principles of federalism. You cannot claim to be a federal republic without going through this procedure. Nigeria did not go through this procedure, which is why the country is a mess today. Let me explain what I think this standard procedure is.

As a first step, the local people, involving tribes, communities, cities and towns, come together to form the first federating unit (whether as a state, local or community government). These local people decide for themselves which powers will be given to their new creation, and also how it will be funded and managed. The local people have full control of and hold the exclusive right to decide how powerful their first federating unit will be.

During the process of creating the first federating unit, there will be compromises. Tribes will unite (where necessary) and in the end, a sustainable autonomous state government will be established as the first federating unit. We must note that a first level federating unit is equivalent to an independent country, but because it wishes to federate further, it refuses to be a country. Please note that in this first stage, the local people created the state government and are therefore internally and solely responsible for its management and funding.

As a second step, if a first level federating unit (a state government) is autonomous as a country, why then should it go ahead to relate with other such federating units to form a country when it can form a country on its own? Its quite simple. There are several reasons why small autonomous states come together to form a bigger state called a federal government (a country). These reasons include security, economic integration, social mobility and the need to be part of a stronger and more powerful country. Afterall, the first federating units have nothing to lose if they form a bigger state. Becoming part of a bigger state does not make them lose their autonomy. Rather it makes them stronger.

Because of the above reasons, autonomous first level federating states then come together to create a federal government. Note that it is the autonomous states that create the federal government and can, therefore, also terminate it. In order not to lose their autonomy, the now united first level federating units decide which powers will be given to this their new creation (federal government) and how it will be funded. Each of the first federating units also have an inalienable right to pull out of the arrangement if it is no longer favourable to them in the future. This is why a referendum is fundamental in every federal constitution. At the end of the day and in most cases, the united first federating units end up giving a limited power to the federal government (which it just created), while holding back other powers. The powers given to the federal government by these units will likely include defence, foreign policy, immigration and customs. Every other political and economic power is withheld by the autonomous federating units (state governments).

This is the standard way of creating a federal government. Note that it is the local people that create their own local councils and state governments, and then the the state governments go ahead to create the federal government. This is what is called a bottom-up approach to governance. There is internal accountability from the top to the bottom. There is legitimacy and a sense of patriotism. There is no such thing as marginalisation or national resources. There is no fear of a Northern president using Southern resources against their interest. There is no ethnic tension. There is mutual respect. There is competition. There are no monthly allocations from the top, rather it is the bottom that feeds the top because it created the top. And many more benefits. This is what a federal republic looks like. This is what true federalism means.

Now, take a look at how the Federal Republic of Nigeria was created. Using the standard procedure given above, can you see why Nigeria is not working and why it will never work? Nigeria was created through a reversal of the standard procedure! The federal government created the states and local government areas and must therefore fund and sustain them!

Technically, Nigeria is not a legitimate country because more than half of the people and states that make it did not give consent to its creation. A country has legitimacy when ALL of its people give it authority to act on their behalf. If we doubt this, then lets call for a referendum and see the outcome. Standard practice.

If the people that make up Nigeria never came together to establish the country on an agreeable term, then where did the Nigerian state get its legitimacy from?

I find it alarming when purportedly educated people oppose true federalism in Nigeria out of ignorance of the subject matter.
Nigeria is not a federal republic. It is a unitary republic, whose status as a ‘republic’ is actually questionable.

It is time to restructure Nigeria for true federalism.

Tony Osborg writes from Port Harcourt.

Share this:

  • Tweet
  • Email
  • Print
  • More
  • Pocket
  • Share on Tumblr

Related

Previous Post

The Party Has Been Long Over; Let’s Get to Work, By Henry Anibe Agbonika

Next Post

Why Boko Haram Insurgency Can’t Be Said to Be Over, By Atiku Abubakar

Related Posts

Zamfara Gold As Commonwealth, By Zailani Bappa
Opinion

Sheikh Gumi, Governor Matawalle and the Sands of Time, By Zailani Bappa

February 2, 2021
June 12 As Democracy Day Needs To Be Reconsidered, By Bashir Tofa
Opinion

The Need To Act Now To Stop the Ethnic Conflagration!, By Bashir Othman Tofa

February 2, 2021
Kofi Annan: In Service of the World, By Ejeviome Eloho Otobo & Oseloka H. Obaze
Opinion

Biden’s Likely Policy Orientation Toward Africa, By Ejeviome E. Otobo and Oseloka H. Obaze

February 2, 2021
Agenda for ‘Born Again’ JAMB and TETFUND, By Tunde Musibau Akanni
Opinion

Oyeweso, A Celebrated Historian, Ascends the Sixth Floor, By Tunde Akanni

February 2, 2021
Before Nigeria Burns, By Akin Fadeyi
Opinion

Is President Buhari Presiding Over the Last United Nigeria?, By Akin Fadeyi

February 2, 2021
On A Soyinka Prize In ‘Illiteracy’, By Biko Agozino
Opinion

Obasanjo: Only Those Who Did Not Do Well Went Into the Military, By Biko Agozino

February 1, 2021
Next Post
Truly Atikulated at 69, By Mazi Paul Ibe

Why Boko Haram Insurgency Can't Be Said to Be Over, By Atiku Abubakar

Why Lai Mohammed Must Be Fired Immediately, By Femi Aribisala

Good and Bad Success, By Femi Aribisala

Editorial

  • EDITORIAL: The Urgency of Tackling Nigeria’s Second Wave of COVID-19

    EDITORIAL: The Urgency of Tackling Nigeria’s Second Wave of COVID-19

  • EDITORIAL: Unearthing the Cogent Lessons In the NESG-CBN Economic Policy Imbroglio

    EDITORIAL: Unearthing the Cogent Lessons In the NESG-CBN Economic Policy Imbroglio

  • EDITORIAL: COVID-19: Calling On Nigeria’s Billionaires and Religious Leaders To Step Up

    EDITORIAL: COVID-19: Calling On Nigeria’s Billionaires and Religious Leaders To Step Up

  • EDITORIAL: Bichi Must Go; Buhari Must Halt Slide Into Despotism

    EDITORIAL: Bichi Must Go; Buhari Must Halt Slide Into Despotism

  • EDITORIAL: The Flaws In Governor Emefiele’s Five-Year Plan For Central Bank of Nigeria

    EDITORIAL: The Flaws In Governor Emefiele’s Five-Year Plan For Central Bank of Nigeria

Subscribe to our Opinion articles via email

Enter your email address to get notifications of new opinion articles as they are published.

Join 526,545 other subscribers

Most Popular

  • The Bad Consequences and Dangers of Adultery and Fornication (Zina) In Islam, By Murtadha Gusau
    The Bad Consequences and Dangers of Adultery and Fornication (Zina) In Islam, By Murtadha Gusau
  • The Qualities of a Good Leader In Islam, By Murtadha Gusau
    The Qualities of a Good Leader In Islam, By Murtadha Gusau
  • Islam and the Conditions For Marrying More Than One Wife, By Murtadha Gusau
    Islam and the Conditions For Marrying More Than One Wife, By Murtadha Gusau
  • World Teachers Day and The Position of Teachers In Islam, By Murtadha Gusau
    World Teachers Day and The Position of Teachers In Islam, By Murtadha Gusau
  • You Will Be Held Responsible On What Happened To Your Children!, By Murtadha Gusau
    You Will Be Held Responsible On What Happened To Your Children!, By Murtadha Gusau
  • The Dangers of Evil and Misguided Clerics/Scholars In Islam, By Murtadha Gusau
    The Dangers of Evil and Misguided Clerics/Scholars In Islam, By Murtadha Gusau
  • The Women Prohibited For Men To Marry In Islam, By Murtadha Gusau
    The Women Prohibited For Men To Marry In Islam, By Murtadha Gusau

Like us on Facebook

Like us on Facebook

Podcasts

Advertisement

Advertisement

Advertisement

  • Main News
  • About Us
  • Contact

© 2023 JNews - Premium WordPress news & magazine theme by Jegtheme.

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Democracy and Governance
    • Bámidélé Upfront
    • Jibrin Ibrahim
    • Okey Ndibe
  • Economy
    • Ifeanyi Uddin
  • Issues of the Day
    • Adeolu Ademoyo
    • Aribisala on Tuesday
    • Dele Agekameh
    • Pius Adesanmi
  • Politics
    • Ebeneezer Obadare
    • Femi Fani-Kayode
    • Garba Shehu
    • Hannatu Musawa
    • Zainab Suleiman Okino
  • Guest Columns
  • Faith
    • Article of Faith
    • Sunday Ogidigbo
    • Friday Sermon
    • Elevated Sight

© 2023 JNews - Premium WordPress news & magazine theme by Jegtheme.

This website uses cookies. By continuing to use this website you are giving consent to cookies being used. Visit our Privacy and Cookie Policy.
 

Loading Comments...