• Main News
  • About Us
  • Contact
Premium Times Opinion
Sunday, January 29, 2023
  • Home
  • Democracy and Governance
    • Bámidélé Upfront
    • Jibrin Ibrahim
    • Okey Ndibe
  • Economy
    • Ifeanyi Uddin
  • Issues of the Day
    • Adeolu Ademoyo
    • Aribisala on Tuesday
    • Dele Agekameh
    • Pius Adesanmi
  • Politics
    • Ebeneezer Obadare
    • Femi Fani-Kayode
    • Garba Shehu
    • Hannatu Musawa
    • Zainab Suleiman Okino
  • Guest Columns
  • Faith
    • Article of Faith
    • Sunday Ogidigbo
    • Friday Sermon
    • Elevated Sight
  • Home
  • Democracy and Governance
    • Bámidélé Upfront
    • Jibrin Ibrahim
    • Okey Ndibe
  • Economy
    • Ifeanyi Uddin
  • Issues of the Day
    • Adeolu Ademoyo
    • Aribisala on Tuesday
    • Dele Agekameh
    • Pius Adesanmi
  • Politics
    • Ebeneezer Obadare
    • Femi Fani-Kayode
    • Garba Shehu
    • Hannatu Musawa
    • Zainab Suleiman Okino
  • Guest Columns
  • Faith
    • Article of Faith
    • Sunday Ogidigbo
    • Friday Sermon
    • Elevated Sight
No Result
View All Result
Premium Times Opinion

It Takes a Village: Making Primary Health Contracts Work, By Seember Nyager

by Premium Times
December 8, 2016
Reading Time: 6 mins read
2

primary-healthcare-centre

The concept of PHCs in Nigeria envisages collective ownership by the community. In truth, getting value from health procurement requires mechanisms for coordination across the public sector, and across tiers of government towards improved health access. It also requires informed citizens at every level, knowledgeable about government’s plans and providing feedback on implementation.


In the space of a few months, my classmates and I lost two beautiful women to medical complications during childbirth. This is not uncommon and most Nigerians have a friend, a colleague, a family member who has suffered a similar fate. The statistics devastate. According to the United Nations, 10 percent of global maternal mortality is from Nigeria. To break it down further, 111 women die daily from childbirth in Nigeria. A part of the challenge is that our tertiary healthcare institutions are overburdened with cases that ought to be attended to at the primary healthcare level. This may partly explain the Nigerian government’s decision to ensure that there is a primary health care centre (PHC) within a five mile radius in each community.
imota
And so every year, new PHC contracts across Nigeria are awarded. In 2014, for example, according to data available on Budeshi provided by the National Primary Health Care Development Agency (NPHCDA), the Federal Government awarded 89 contracts worth 2.6 billion naira for the construction of PHCs. Two years on, when it is safe to assume that these contracts have been fully executed, we randomly select 40 of these PHCs and conduct a basic performance assessment to understand how well they are contributing to improved access in the communities where they are located. Our assessment makes it strikingly clear that it would take much more than construction contracts to improve primary health care access. This would require adequate planning, coordination across government tiers and sectors and a system that enables public accountability.

Breaking the Silos

The provision of primary healthcare services is a responsibility administered by the third tier of government, the local government. The Federal and State Governments provide various levels of support to the local governments, particularly by constructing PHCs. In 2014, at least 89 contracts worth 2.6 billion naira were awarded by the Federal Government through the NPHCDA. From the perspective of procurement monitors, five of the six PHCs visited in the South-Western region of the country (Lagos, Oyo, Ogun and Osun states) are operating fully, but these five PHCs are the exception. The majority of the PHC construction contracts visited have been completed but are not functional and in some cases, it is impossible to locate the PHCs.

In Benue State, for example, four out of the six PHC construction contracts awarded in 2014 were completed in 2015 but till date none of them has been commissioned. This is also the case with an earlier reported primary healthcare centre in Abuja and is similar to the PHCs in Yaryassa, Tudun Wada Local government area of Kano State which is open but unable to provide any medical service because there are no medical facilities or personnel.

While the NPHCDA rightly situates the responsibility for primary healthcare as one to be administered by the local government, we discovered that for some of these PHC contracts, such as the Abuja PHC earlier referred to, the area council, which is the equivalent of a local government, knew nothing about its development until the structure was being erected. The result is that till date, the PHC is non-functional because there was no plan at the local government level to staff and maintain it.
phc-budeshi
Without disregard to the structure of autonomy between the Federal, State and Local governments, it is wasteful for PHCs to be built by the Federal Government with insufficient coordination across all the tiers of government to ensure that the structures are actually utilised to provide healthcare access.

The Missing PHC in Burutu Local Government

Under the Nigerian procurement law, a contract cannot be formalised without available funds to meet the obligation and so if procurement data indicates that a contract is awarded, there is a presumption that the contract award is cash-backed.

In some instances, there is a liaison between the Federal and the Local Government to provide primary healthcare centres. This was the case in 2013 when community members of Burutu Local Government in Delta State specifically requested that the Federal Government’s NPHCDA provide them with a primary healthcare centre. Thereafter, the NPHCDA wrote back to the community to inform them of plans underway to grant the request by building PHCs in the identified local governments including Burutu. The community was informed at a later date of the published tender for the PHC and then no further information was received. A few years after this request was made, and using Budeshi data provided by NPHCDA, procurement monitors visited Burutu in August 2016, and they were told that no such PHC was built in 2014; indeed the last PHC built in Burutu was in 2002. The absence of a PHC built in 2014 in Burutu local government was confirmed by the same community member who had written to NPHCDA in 2013 requesting for a PHC. In the presence of the chair of the legislative house committee on health and several other representatives from public institutions, the Burutu community confirmed that no granite stone touched the soil for the construction of a PHC in the area in 2014 or any year after that.

The challenge is that procurement data for Burutu provided by the NPHCDA indicates that the contract was awarded in 2014 to Baking Consults Limited for over 21 million naira.

Burutu is one of several PHcs that could not be located but for which contract award data is available, and under our procurement law, a contract cannot be formalised without available funds to meet the contract obligation. And so if procurement data indicates that a contract is awarded, there is a presumption that the contract award is cash-backed.
phc-budeshi-2
It Takes a Village

When PHC data suggests that contracts have been awarded and there is no contrary information from the agencies to suggest that such contracts were terminated, our minds go to the worst possible scenario. The resources have been diverted.

Such impressions can be avoided with a commitment to making contract-related data available at every stage in the process that leads to full implementation of the project. The exact location of the contract, the specifications of each contract, and the milestones for payment, should be publicly accessible, in a way that links the various contracting stages, so that stakeholders across board are empowered to follow the money right to service delivery. That way, we are able to trace how well our public contracts are meeting our health needs. From the current report that links procurement data to PHCs, the executive and the legislature are duty-bound to further investigate these states of affair, set the records straight, ensure funds expended have been utilised for the purpose for which they were provided and ensure that this viscious cycle of non-functioning PHCs does not recur.

The concept of PHCs in Nigeria envisages collective ownership by the community. In truth, getting value from health procurement requires mechanisms for coordination across the public sector, and across tiers of government towards improved health access. It also requires informed citizens at every level, knowledgeable about government’s plans and providing feedback on implementation. True to its original concept, improved access to primary healthcare is not the sole responsibility of the health department at the local government; it takes a village. In our case, it takes a nation.

Our comprehensive report that links procurement data to primary health care centres in 7 states is available here.

Seember is curator for http://www.budeshi.org, CEO of @ppmonitorNG and tweets @Seember1

This article first appeared on www.budeshi.org.

Share this:

  • Tweet
  • Email
  • Print
  • More
  • Pocket
  • Share on Tumblr

Related

Previous Post

Nigerian Constitutions: Our Pretence on Traditional Rulers, By Eric Teniola

Next Post

A Daughter’s Letter And A Difficult Reply, By Azu Ishiekwene

Related Posts

Zamfara Gold As Commonwealth, By Zailani Bappa
Opinion

Sheikh Gumi, Governor Matawalle and the Sands of Time, By Zailani Bappa

February 2, 2021
June 12 As Democracy Day Needs To Be Reconsidered, By Bashir Tofa
Opinion

The Need To Act Now To Stop the Ethnic Conflagration!, By Bashir Othman Tofa

February 2, 2021
Kofi Annan: In Service of the World, By Ejeviome Eloho Otobo & Oseloka H. Obaze
Opinion

Biden’s Likely Policy Orientation Toward Africa, By Ejeviome E. Otobo and Oseloka H. Obaze

February 2, 2021
Agenda for ‘Born Again’ JAMB and TETFUND, By Tunde Musibau Akanni
Opinion

Oyeweso, A Celebrated Historian, Ascends the Sixth Floor, By Tunde Akanni

February 2, 2021
Before Nigeria Burns, By Akin Fadeyi
Opinion

Is President Buhari Presiding Over the Last United Nigeria?, By Akin Fadeyi

February 2, 2021
On A Soyinka Prize In ‘Illiteracy’, By Biko Agozino
Opinion

Obasanjo: Only Those Who Did Not Do Well Went Into the Military, By Biko Agozino

February 1, 2021
Next Post
Ministerial Lists And The Other List, By Azu Ishiekwene

A Daughter’s Letter And A Difficult Reply, By Azu Ishiekwene

Crowding the Private Sector into Africa’s Climate Action, By Chinedu Moghalu

Crowding the Private Sector into Africa’s Climate Action, By Chinedu Moghalu

Editorial

  • EDITORIAL: The Urgency of Tackling Nigeria’s Second Wave of COVID-19

    EDITORIAL: The Urgency of Tackling Nigeria’s Second Wave of COVID-19

  • EDITORIAL: Unearthing the Cogent Lessons In the NESG-CBN Economic Policy Imbroglio

    EDITORIAL: Unearthing the Cogent Lessons In the NESG-CBN Economic Policy Imbroglio

  • EDITORIAL: COVID-19: Calling On Nigeria’s Billionaires and Religious Leaders To Step Up

    EDITORIAL: COVID-19: Calling On Nigeria’s Billionaires and Religious Leaders To Step Up

  • EDITORIAL: Bichi Must Go; Buhari Must Halt Slide Into Despotism

    EDITORIAL: Bichi Must Go; Buhari Must Halt Slide Into Despotism

  • EDITORIAL: The Flaws In Governor Emefiele’s Five-Year Plan For Central Bank of Nigeria

    EDITORIAL: The Flaws In Governor Emefiele’s Five-Year Plan For Central Bank of Nigeria

Subscribe to our Opinion articles via email

Enter your email address to get notifications of new opinion articles as they are published.

Join 526,545 other subscribers

Most Popular

  • The Bad Consequences and Dangers of Adultery and Fornication (Zina) In Islam, By Murtadha Gusau
    The Bad Consequences and Dangers of Adultery and Fornication (Zina) In Islam, By Murtadha Gusau
  • The Qualities of a Good Leader In Islam, By Murtadha Gusau
    The Qualities of a Good Leader In Islam, By Murtadha Gusau
  • Islam and the Conditions For Marrying More Than One Wife, By Murtadha Gusau
    Islam and the Conditions For Marrying More Than One Wife, By Murtadha Gusau
  • World Teachers Day and The Position of Teachers In Islam, By Murtadha Gusau
    World Teachers Day and The Position of Teachers In Islam, By Murtadha Gusau
  • You Will Be Held Responsible On What Happened To Your Children!, By Murtadha Gusau
    You Will Be Held Responsible On What Happened To Your Children!, By Murtadha Gusau
  • The Dangers of Evil and Misguided Clerics/Scholars In Islam, By Murtadha Gusau
    The Dangers of Evil and Misguided Clerics/Scholars In Islam, By Murtadha Gusau
  • The Women Prohibited For Men To Marry In Islam, By Murtadha Gusau
    The Women Prohibited For Men To Marry In Islam, By Murtadha Gusau

Like us on Facebook

Like us on Facebook

Podcasts

Advertisement

Advertisement

Advertisement

  • Main News
  • About Us
  • Contact

© 2023 JNews - Premium WordPress news & magazine theme by Jegtheme.

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Democracy and Governance
    • Bámidélé Upfront
    • Jibrin Ibrahim
    • Okey Ndibe
  • Economy
    • Ifeanyi Uddin
  • Issues of the Day
    • Adeolu Ademoyo
    • Aribisala on Tuesday
    • Dele Agekameh
    • Pius Adesanmi
  • Politics
    • Ebeneezer Obadare
    • Femi Fani-Kayode
    • Garba Shehu
    • Hannatu Musawa
    • Zainab Suleiman Okino
  • Guest Columns
  • Faith
    • Article of Faith
    • Sunday Ogidigbo
    • Friday Sermon
    • Elevated Sight

© 2023 JNews - Premium WordPress news & magazine theme by Jegtheme.

This website uses cookies. By continuing to use this website you are giving consent to cookies being used. Visit our Privacy and Cookie Policy.
 

Loading Comments...