• Main News
  • About Us
  • Contact
Premium Times Opinion
Monday, January 25, 2021
  • Home
  • Democracy and Governance
    • Bámidélé Upfront
    • Jibrin Ibrahim
    • Okey Ndibe
  • Economy
    • Ifeanyi Uddin
  • Issues of the Day
    • Adeolu Ademoyo
    • Aribisala on Tuesday
    • Dele Agekameh
    • Pius Adesanmi
  • Politics
    • Ebeneezer Obadare
    • Femi Fani-Kayode
    • Garba Shehu
    • Hannatu Musawa
    • Zainab Suleiman Okino
  • Guest Columns
  • Faith
    • Article of Faith
    • Sunday Ogidigbo
    • Friday Sermon
    • Elevated Sight
  • Home
  • Democracy and Governance
    • Bámidélé Upfront
    • Jibrin Ibrahim
    • Okey Ndibe
  • Economy
    • Ifeanyi Uddin
  • Issues of the Day
    • Adeolu Ademoyo
    • Aribisala on Tuesday
    • Dele Agekameh
    • Pius Adesanmi
  • Politics
    • Ebeneezer Obadare
    • Femi Fani-Kayode
    • Garba Shehu
    • Hannatu Musawa
    • Zainab Suleiman Okino
  • Guest Columns
  • Faith
    • Article of Faith
    • Sunday Ogidigbo
    • Friday Sermon
    • Elevated Sight
No Result
View All Result
Premium Times Opinion
Home Opinion

Examining the Case In Defence of Nigeria’s Anti-NGO Bill, By Chidi Anselm Odinkalu

by Premium Times
October 4, 2017
5 min read
0

chained-hands

The House boasts that they have borrowed the model from Israel, Kenya and Uganda where the project of “NGO regulation” is to clobber perceived enemies of the government of the day. It may be more honest for them to come out clearly and admit this as their goal. That would help a whole lot in bringing the narrative of the Bill to an honourable conclusion.


Nigeria’s National Assembly (NASS), for long on the defensive over allegations of chronic institutional opacity, appears to have found a way to turn attack into defence. Its device of choice is the NGO Regulatory Bill, which is presently at the committee stage in the House of Representatives. Flipping around the script, the NASS is accusing Nigeria’s voluntary sector of being a den of crooks in need of proper policing.

The proponents of the NGO Bill have organised their defence of its provision around five broad themes. Their arguments deserve attention.

First, the rationale for the Bill. House majority leader, Femi Gbajabiamila, has proffered the most succinct rationale for the Bill, arguing – with no hint of irony – that “NGOs cannot be above the laws of the land. They must be regulated.” This is not an argument that any member of the NASS can credibly make. Ahead of their recess in July 2017, Gbajabiamila led his colleagues in a vote to amend the constitution in order to give themselves immunity, which puts them “above the laws of the land.” The grandiloquence of his claim misleads. Former president of the Civil Liberties Organisation, (CLO), Ayo Obe and Kaine Agary have respectively explained in detail some of the relevant laws governing NGOs in Nigeria. This NGO Bill won’t repeal any of these laws nor abolish any of the institutions that implement them.

The second theme in this debate is the goal of the Bill. If the rationale is misleading at best, the goal is based verifiable inaccuracy. Deputy majority leader, Umar Buba Jubril, who is the sponsor of the Bill, claims that his goal is “to address or cure defects occasioned by the absence of a regulatory framework on the operations and activities of civil society organisations in Nigeria.” This is clearly false. There is an extensive regulatory framework in existence. By its own admission, parliament is not embarking on a review or upgrade of the existing regulatory system. They deny that any such framework exists.

…Deputy Majority Leader Jubril insists, without citing any evidence or naming any group involved that “some NGOs are used to fund the activities of terrorist and insurgents.” This allegation is quite serious. To make it so glibly without any effort at substantiating it is irresponsible.


The third theme is the scope of the Bill. On behalf of the House, majority leader, Gbajabiamila, himself a lawyer, carefully argues that “nowhere in the Bill is there any reference to churches or mosques or old students’ associations.” This is far from saying that the Bill does not cover them as it surely does. Similarly, ‘Tope Fasua, claims that “the bill actually says nothing about religious houses.” The Bill doesn’t have to mention churches or mosques or community, revolving credit institutions (Esusu) in order to apply to them. The explanatory memorandum to the Bill makes it clear that it is for “the supervision, co-ordination and monitoring” of NGOs, CSOs and community-based organisations (CBOs) in Nigeria. To begin with, Esusu are CBOs. Churches and mosques are too. However, section 57 of the Bill defines an NGO as “a private voluntary grouping of individuals or associations, not operated for profit or for other commercial purposes but which have organised themselves nationally or internationally for the promotion of social welfare, development, charity, or research through the mobilisation of resources.” By defining NGOs to include “charities”, the Bill covers churches and mosques immediately. The advancement of religion is a core charitable object. In any case, it would be difficult to cast a provision that can lawfully exclude churches and mosques from the scope of the Bill. Any such effort would reveal an insidious design in the Bill against advocacy NGOs. Such a provision would almost surely fail as an attack on free speech and association and a license to political persecution.

Fourth, its supporters argue that the Bill is meant to catch crooks masquerading as NGOs but that’s the role of criminal law. ‘Tope Fasua attempts to give this line of reasoning some respectability and Deputy Majority Leader Jubril insists, without citing any evidence or naming any group involved that “some NGOs are used to fund the activities of terrorist and insurgents.” This allegation is quite serious. To make it so glibly without any effort at substantiating it is irresponsible. If any NGO is involved in such an act, it is a serious crime. We don’t need new laws to put it out of business or to sanction its leadership. If the deputy majority leader knows of any such group and has failed to bring them to the attention of the security agencies, he commits a crime and diminishes his office. What is verifiable is that the report of the Gaji Galtimari Presidential Committee on the insecurity in the North-East in 2011 traced the origins of Boko Haram “to political aspirants who set them up in the run up to the 2003 general elections”, and tasked “the security agencies to beam their investigative searchlight on some key politicians who sponsored and funded and used the militia groups that metamorphosed into Boko Haram and bring them to justice.” Six years later, that has not been done. Some of these politicians could indeed be among those calling NGOs terrorists.

Short of coherent rationales or goals and confused about the scope of the Bill or its functions, its proponents can’t point to one feature that can redeem it. It’s difficult to see how it can possibly be improved.


Fifth, there are those in the “constructive criticism” school, like Bashir Yusuf Ibrahim, who counsel dissenters from the Bill to “suggest how the bill could be improved, not to reject it in its entirety as they presently do.” Short of coherent rationales or goals and confused about the scope of the Bill or its functions, its proponents can’t point to one feature that can redeem it. It’s difficult to see how it can possibly be improved.

The House boasts that they have borrowed the model from Israel, Kenya and Uganda where the project of “NGO regulation” is to clobber perceived enemies of the government of the day. It may be more honest for them to come out clearly and admit this as their goal. That would help a whole lot in bringing the narrative of the Bill to an honourable conclusion.

Chidi Anselm Odinkalu chairs the Council of the Section on Public Interest and Development Law (SPIDEL) of the Nigerian Bar Association (NBA).

Share this:

  • Tweet
  • Print
  • More
  • Pocket
  • Share on Tumblr

Related

Previous Post

Restructuring: This Too Shall Come To Pass, By Zainab Suleiman Okino

Next Post

October 1 and the Torment of Memory, By Louis Odion

Related Posts

Akinwunmi Adesina: Africa’s Spotless Son, By Wole Olaoye
Opinion

Democratisation of Insecurity, By Wole Olaoye

January 24, 2021
Jega, You Saved Nigeria from Another Coup, By Simon Imobo-Tswam
Opinion

Restructuring In Nigeria: Why? How? When?, By Attahiru M. Jega

January 24, 2021
Nigeria: A Country of Zero Consequence For Misdeed, By Umar Yakubu
Opinion

Time To Have More Gumis In Society: When Action Speaks Louder Than Words, By Umar Yakubu

January 24, 2021
Rethinking Heroism and the Nigerian Civil Service, By Festus Adedayo
Columns

Sunday Igboho and the Spirit of Ogbori Elemoso, By Festus Adedayo

January 24, 2021
Trump and the Limits of A ‘Failed Experiment!’, By Femi Mimiko
Opinion

Trump and the Limits of A ‘Failed Experiment!’, By Femi Mimiko

January 24, 2021
Options for Nigeria’s Clean Energy Future, By Mohammed Dahiru Aminu
Opinion

Of Toyin Falola, African Scholars and the Western Academy, By Mohammed Dahiru Aminu

January 24, 2021
Next Post
Endgame & Abacha’s Last Disciple, By Louis Odion

October 1 and the Torment of Memory, By Louis Odion

Towards 2019: The Executive and Legislature Power Intrigues, By Rafiq Raji

Kachikwu’s Reality, By Rafiq Raji

Editorial

  • EDITORIAL: Unearthing the Cogent Lessons In the NESG-CBN Economic Policy Imbroglio

    EDITORIAL: Unearthing the Cogent Lessons In the NESG-CBN Economic Policy Imbroglio

  • EDITORIAL: COVID-19: Calling On Nigeria’s Billionaires and Religious Leaders To Step Up

    EDITORIAL: COVID-19: Calling On Nigeria’s Billionaires and Religious Leaders To Step Up

  • EDITORIAL: Bichi Must Go; Buhari Must Halt Slide Into Despotism

    EDITORIAL: Bichi Must Go; Buhari Must Halt Slide Into Despotism

  • EDITORIAL: The Flaws In Governor Emefiele’s Five-Year Plan For Central Bank of Nigeria

    EDITORIAL: The Flaws In Governor Emefiele’s Five-Year Plan For Central Bank of Nigeria

  • EDITORIAL: President Buhari Must Release Sowore Now!

    EDITORIAL: President Buhari Must Release Sowore Now!

Subscribe to our Opinion articles via email

Enter your email address to get notifications of new opinion articles as they are published.

Join 526,505 other subscribers

Most Popular

  • Sunday Igboho and the Spirit of Ogbori Elemoso, By Festus Adedayo
    Sunday Igboho and the Spirit of Ogbori Elemoso, By Festus Adedayo
  • Restructuring In Nigeria: Why? How? When?, By Attahiru M. Jega
    Restructuring In Nigeria: Why? How? When?, By Attahiru M. Jega
  • Of Toyin Falola, African Scholars and the Western Academy, By Mohammed Dahiru Aminu
    Of Toyin Falola, African Scholars and the Western Academy, By Mohammed Dahiru Aminu
  • Trump and the Limits of A ‘Failed Experiment!’, By Femi Mimiko
    Trump and the Limits of A ‘Failed Experiment!’, By Femi Mimiko
  • Time To Have More Gumis In Society: When Action Speaks Louder Than Words, By Umar Yakubu
    Time To Have More Gumis In Society: When Action Speaks Louder Than Words, By Umar Yakubu
  • Free Will Does Not Exist (2), By Femi Aribisala
    Free Will Does Not Exist (2), By Femi Aribisala
  • Democratisation of Insecurity, By Wole Olaoye
    Democratisation of Insecurity, By Wole Olaoye

Like us on Facebook

Like us on Facebook

Podcasts

Advertisement

Advertisement

Advertisement

  • Main News
  • About Us
  • Contact

© 2021 JNews - Premium WordPress news & magazine theme by Jegtheme.

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Democracy and Governance
    • Bámidélé Upfront
    • Jibrin Ibrahim
    • Okey Ndibe
  • Economy
    • Ifeanyi Uddin
  • Issues of the Day
    • Adeolu Ademoyo
    • Aribisala on Tuesday
    • Dele Agekameh
    • Pius Adesanmi
  • Politics
    • Ebeneezer Obadare
    • Femi Fani-Kayode
    • Garba Shehu
    • Hannatu Musawa
    • Zainab Suleiman Okino
  • Guest Columns
  • Faith
    • Article of Faith
    • Sunday Ogidigbo
    • Friday Sermon
    • Elevated Sight

© 2021 JNews - Premium WordPress news & magazine theme by Jegtheme.

This website uses cookies. By continuing to use this website you are giving consent to cookies being used. Visit our Privacy and Cookie Policy.